(Submitted February 21, 1998)
I have heard two conflicting reasons explaining why winter is cooler.
(1) Because of the slight pivot of Earth's on its axis, the Sun is
farther away during winter because part of the planet is pointing away
from the Sun, hence, less energy reaches that surface.
(2) The Sun is actually CLOSER to the surface during winter but light
hits the planet at an obtuse angle which "skims" the surface. Direct
rays are not hitting the surface which brings about cooler temperatures.
Which explanation is correct?
Winter is colder because the earth's axis is tilted. Winter occurs for
the hemisphere which is tilted away from the Sun (the northern hemisphere
in January, the southern in July). This has two main effects on the
winter hemisphere. First, the Sun is above the horizon for fewer hours
each day, so that hemisphere receives less heat from the sun. Also,
sunlight strikes the ground at a shallower angle so that less energy per
unit area is intercepted by the winter hemisphere. It is true that the
earth is closest to the Sun in January. However, the distance from the
earth to the Sun varies by only about 2% over a year. This causes a
change of only 4% in the amount of solar radiation hitting the earth so
this effect is not significant compared to the other two.
Damian Audley and Kevin Boyce
for Ask an Astrophysicist.
Questions on this topic are no longer responded to by the "Ask an Astrophysicist" service. See http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/ask_an_astronomer.html
for help on other astronomy Q&A services.